Application for High Density Appartments Denied, For Now
Last night the City Council voted
unanimously to deny the application by Ron Martinez of America West
for approval of the project master plan of "Park Place".
The plan as presented at the meeting showed the project having 7
buildings with 24 apartment units each for a total number of 168
units. However the Mayor pointed out that proposed plan was
ambiguous enough to possibly allow for well over 300 units. The
development also called for a 10,000 sq. ft. restaurant and office
space in a two level building and another building with a credit
union. A club house with pool, hot tub, and play ground were
specified as community amenities.
Ron Martinez explained that America West would not ultimately be
the builders. America West has letters of intent from large
apartment management companies who will ultimately build the
apartments. The banks and restaurant/office will be built by
their respective owners. The whole development would be a $25
million investment for all involved. The rest of his 148 acres
up the tracks would be roughly a $150 million investment.
A
dozen or so Farmington residents spoke against the proposal with Ron
Martinez, two individuals of his team, and a SLC developer
speaking for it. Unexpectedly (at least from a residents
perspective) was that the real fireworks was between the Mayor/City
Council and the developer and his team. The developer had taken
real issue to the the City's TOD (transit oriented development)
zoning ordinance. To the developer the ordinance was much too
ambiguous leaving them frustrated at delays by City staff and
"subjectivity" imposed by the Planning Commission and the
City Council. The City fired back by pointing out equal
ambiguity in the developer's project master plan.
This was a
small battle won by those who oppose dense housing in Farmington.
However this parcel will be developed and the City does seem to be
sympathetic to building some level of high density housing (non
single family units) there. They just didn't like America
West's current proposal.
Up next in the shaping of the look
and feel of west Farmington is the battle for changes in the TOD
zoning ordinance text. The planning commission will hold a
special meeting with a public hearing on August 7th at 7:00PM to
discuss the text changes of the TOD zoning ordinance.
The TOD zoning ordinance text is
absolutely critical to get right as developers internalize this law
when planning their development projects. The City is legally bound
to approve development plans that comply with the zoning ordinance.
This is why the City Council and Planning Commission are scrambling
to get new TOD zoning text approved.